Evan Smith. Kaci Campbell. Morgan Lolar.
Evan Smith and Kaci Campbell was the most interesting couple during the season. Kaci was 1,000 percent confident in her relationship with Evan. In fact, during a bonfire, she had a chance to watch a video that would given her evidence of Evan's behavior and status; however, she chose not to watch the video. As they say, ignorance is bliss. Would you want to find out details about your significant other's behavior that will help you make a decision regarding your relationship?
In the end, Evan chose one of the singles, Morgan Lolar. He proposed to her after the show. They lived in Virginia for most of their relationship, and they recently relocated to California. Unfortunately, during early 2020 their relationship ended because Evan allegedly cheated (as per Morgan's Instagram account). In this case, past behavior became a predictor of future behavior.
Karl Collins and Nicole Tutewohl
Karl Collins and Nicole Tutewohl from Chicago, also experienced the challenge of temptation. They were in a relationship for two years prior to joining the cast of Temptation Island. Nicole gained insight about herself, and their relationship. She decided that she wanted to venture out on her own during the finale episode. During the season, Karl had a single on the Island who showed him romantic interest, but he didn't pick her during the finale. He appeared disappointed with Nicole's decision.
Javen Butler and Shari Ligons
Javen Butler and Shari Ligons both remained dedicated to each other while on Temptation Island Season 1. They have been together since the age of 16. In fact, neither of them even opened up for an emotional attachment with the singles. At the end of the show, Javen proposed to Shari. They are still engaged today.
John Thurmond and Kady Krambeer.
John Thurmond and Kady Krambeer from Fort Worth, Texas, were also on Season 1 of Temptation Island. Kady had what a lot of women prefer, a man who is dedicated to them. However, Kady found fault with John, and decided to go her separate way. She dated one of the singles from the Island after the show for a short period.